Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Tragedy & Hope in 21st C.'s avatar

The general idea of the article is correct because the conflation of Israel and Jewry has placed multitudes of non-Israeli Jews, who in many cases oppose Israeli actions, in a very difficult situation. However, the article perpetuates the typical rhetoric of those who are being criticized.

It might be worth remembering that Jews expelled from Spain were accepted by the Muslim world and that, in general, Jews lived much better under Muslim rule than under Christian rule over the ages.

The relationship became more complicated only after the state of Israel was established, primarily because of the atrocities committed by the new state.

Furthermore, there is a lively Jewish community in Iran whose synagogue was recently bombed by the U.S. and Israel.

(https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2026/4/7/synagogue-in-tehran-destroyed-in-us-israeli-strikes-on-iran)

Also, I have never heard Iranian officials speak against Jews as such, but rather against the state of Israel or Zionism.

Moreover, I have spent a reasonable amount of time going through the communication channels of various parties engaged in the current crisis, and I can say that, when it came to the Iranian ones, I did not find memes targeting Jews in general. Instead, I found many targeting Israeli Jews as representatives of Iran’s adversary in a war inflicted on it. There was no racial subtext, and as Haaretz reported that 93% of Israeli Jews supported the attack on Iran, a certain level of emotional response is to be expected.

Paradoxically, I found that a plethora of anti-Jewish memes came from right-wing Christian sources and, in some cases, from channels related to Lebanon.

The case of Lebanon is related to the ongoing experience of targeted killings, the bombing of civilian population, settlement expansion, asset dispossession, settler violence against the original inhabitants, and so on. All of that is being done by Israeli Jews. This may be the reason for the hatred expressed in channels related to Lebanon. You might rightfully argue that a proportionally much smaller part of Israeli citizens of Arab origin also supported the war, but I doubt they would be trusted enough to be deployed by the IDF in Lebanon, nor do I think they are taking part in recent settlement projects. This probably explains why Jews are blamed.

It is very hard to maintain any calm distinction when your relatives are being killed and an entire town, including your home, is being flattened. I think what we are doing here is having a sort of cool-headed academic discussion, but the reality for the people experiencing this, on both sides, is very different. Hatred feeds hatred, and the loop continues endlessly.

If you corner someone, they will fear you first but after some time they will hate you. This is natural psychological response.

On one side, the Palestinians have, starting with the Nakba and even before, been increasingly cornered for decades, and they feel that they are fighting for their last breath, which makes them very serious opponents even though they have been decimated.

On the other side, Israeli Jews are cornering themselves by pushing the Palestinians off their land. They are afraid of the reaction to their actions, and this fear is fueling their hatred.

The only way out of this deadly loop was closed off by the murder of the exceptional Israeli prime minister who, even though he was a Zionist, realized that the country was on the road to hell and had the inner strength to do something about it.

The current trajectory of Israel leads to its destruction, and it does not matter whether that comes by external force or through the complete moral and psychological destruction of its citizens. Either of those, or even both, will inevitably bring about its end.

---

As for right-wing Christians, they also feel cornered. They voted for a president who was supposed to focus on solving their problems and stop waging forever wars that contributed greatly to the astronomical debt the U.S. carries.

Instead, they see this president pouring money into just another war that brings neither any benefit to the U.S. nor any to the rest of the world, except for Israel. They feel that U.S. politics has been hijacked by Israel and blame American Jews for this. The truth is that not every Jew in the U.S. contributed to this, but many supported organizations that, ipso facto, lobbied for Israeli interests on many levels and over the years created the situation we are now in. I think this is what drives these feelings.

What would really help here is something I do not see happening very often, except among a few people such as you. I mean U.S. Jews openly distancing themselves from organizations like AIPAC, the ADL, and others, and thus delegitimizing them.

Starting new Jewish organizations free of Zionist ideology would also help greatly, because the interest of U.S. Jews lies in having a prosperous country where they now live, unless they are counting on the social benefits to which they would be entitled because of their dual citizenship. And even in that case, let us be reasonable, who would fly across the ocean just to get healthcare for free? It is much better to make it affordable in your homeland, in the U.S.

Mark Paul's avatar

Glad you brought up the Rabin assassination. Either Ben Gvir or Smotrich (or maybe both) had a portrait of the assassin hanging on his living room wall. Only when he (or they) became members of the security cabinet was the portrait taken down. Or maybe moved to a less conspicuous place.

25 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?